Brilliant Earth Return Policy (With or Without Receipt)
Brilliant Earth offers a 30 day return and exchange policy on most orders, with a full refund to your original payment method and a free FedEx return label. Items must be returned unworn, and the 30 days start when your purchase is available for shipment or pickup. Orders placed between November 1 and December 15 are covered by an extended holiday window and can be returned through January 15. Returns under $1,000 can be started online, while larger orders are returned by phone at 800.691.0952.
Brilliant Earth Return Policy at a Glance
Here is a quick summary of the rules most shoppers need before they start a return.
| Policy Detail | What Brilliant Earth Says |
|---|---|
| Standard return window | 30 days from when the purchase is available for shipment or pickup |
| Holiday return window | Orders placed November 1 to December 15 can be returned through January 15 |
| Condition required | Unworn, with all promotional gifts included |
| Refund method | Original payment method |
| Return shipping | Free FedEx label, fully insured when you follow the packing steps |
| Refund processing | About 5 business days after your return is received |
| Card refund timing | Another 4 to 7 business days to appear on your account |
| Online return portal | Unworn items under $1,000 shipped within the US |
| Phone returns | 800.691.0952, for all eligible orders |
| Engraving removal fee | $40 when returning an engraved ring |
| Restocking fee | None listed in the official policy |
Extended Holiday Return Window for 2026
For the 2026 holiday season, Brilliant Earth has stretched its standard 30 day guarantee. Any item ordered between November 1 and December 15 is eligible for the extended policy and can be returned through January 15 for an exchange or full refund.
This is useful if you are buying a ring or gift early and will not see the recipient until later. The usual rules still apply, so the jewelry must be unworn and in its original condition. Holiday terms are seasonal, so confirm the current dates on the official returns page before you rely on them.
Brilliant Earth Return Policy With Receipt
A printed receipt is not the only way to prove your purchase, and Brilliant Earth does not ask for a paper receipt by name. What you do need is the paperwork that comes with the return process itself. Keeping these documents together makes a return faster and avoids delays.
- Your order confirmation email, which shows the order details and date
- The return confirmation email, which contains your order number and return shipping authorization number
- The original packaging and any promotional gifts that came with the order
- The FedEx receipt you get when you drop off the package, which acts as proof of insurance
It also helps to keep any certificates or documents that arrived with your diamond or jewelry. If you plan to use the online portal, have the order number from your confirmation email ready before you begin.
Brilliant Earth Return Policy Without Receipt
The official policy does not list a receipt as a requirement for returns. What it does require is a return shipping authorization number, and packages that arrive without one will not be accepted for a refund. That number is issued when you start the return by phone or through the online portal.
If you have lost your receipt or order confirmation email, the safest step is to call 800.691.0952 and explain your situation to customer service. Phone is also the method Brilliant Earth uses for most returns and exchanges. Whatever happens, do not ship anything back until you have received your authorization number.
What Can You Return to Brilliant Earth?
Most orders placed with Brilliant Earth can be returned or exchanged within the return window. The jewelry must be unworn and in its original condition, and any free gifts that came with your order must be sent back too. You are welcome to keep the complimentary jewelry cleaner.
Returns are accepted for orders shipped from any address, including addresses outside the US. Orders that were shipped outside the US must be returned by phone rather than through the online portal.
What Brilliant Earth Does Not Accept for Return
Some purchases are excluded from the standard return policy. Check this list before you start so you do not pay to ship back an item that cannot be refunded.
| Item | Return Status |
|---|---|
| Orders outside the 30 day window, including layaway orders | Not eligible |
| Engraved fine jewelry | Not eligible for a standard return, but an engraved ring can be returned for a $40 engraving removal fee |
| Personalized fine jewelry, such as name necklaces | Not eligible |
| Custom designed jewelry | Not eligible |
| Orders altered while in process | Not eligible |
| Rings that have been resized or modified | Not eligible |
| Items repaired or modified after purchase | Not eligible |
| Items received as an exchange | Not eligible |
| Items bought through the Lifetime Diamond Upgrade Program | Final sale |
| Gift cards | Cannot be returned or redeemed for cash |
How to Return Brilliant Earth Jewelry by Phone
Calling is the main way to return or exchange an order, and it works for every eligible order. Follow these steps in order.
- Call 800.691.0952. Brilliant Earth will email you a return shipping authorization number and a free FedEx return label.
- Pack your jewelry in its original packaging, then double box it using the steps in the packing section below.
- Write the authorization number on the outside of the box and attach the FedEx label.
- Take the package to a FedEx staffed location and ask for a receipt that confirms shipment.
The authorization number is active for seven days from the date it is issued. Your package must ship within that period. If it expires, call again to request a new one.
How to Return Online for Items Under $1,000
The online return portal is the quickest option for smaller orders. It works for unworn products under $1,000 that are within the 30 day window and were shipped within the US.
- Open the Brilliant Earth return portal and enter your order details.
- Choose how you want to send the return. You can print a FedEx label, use a FedEx Mobile QR code, or drop the item at one of the Brilliant Earth showrooms.
- Follow the on screen return instructions. Your order number is in your return confirmation email.
Phone Returns vs Online Returns
Not every order can go through the portal. This table shows which method to use.
| Situation | Best Method |
|---|---|
| Unworn item under $1,000 shipped in the US | Online portal or phone |
| Item over $1,000 | Phone only |
| Order shipped outside the US | Phone only |
| Create Your Own fine jewelry | Phone only |
| Create Your Own engagement ring | Phone only |
| Engraved ring | Phone only |
| Exchange | Phone |
How to Pack Your Brilliant Earth Return
Packing correctly protects both your jewelry and your insurance coverage. Brilliant Earth guarantees full insurance only when you use its free label and follow the packaging instructions, including double boxing.
- Place the jewelry back in its original packaging.
- If you no longer have the original packaging, put the jewelry box inside a small FedEx Priority box and seal it, then place that box inside a medium FedEx Priority box.
- Include any promotional gifts that came with your purchase.
- Seal the outer box and mark out any old addresses or barcodes.
- Write your shipping authorization number on the outside and attach the FedEx label.
Drop the package at a FedEx staffed location and ask for a receipt. Brilliant Earth and FedEx are not responsible for packages left in FedEx drop boxes or at locations that are not FedEx staffed.
Brilliant Earth Refund Timeline and Method
Once your return arrives, the Quality Assurance team inspects it to confirm the item is unworn and that all promotional gifts are included. Your refund is then processed about 5 business days after the package is received.
Refunds go back to the original method of payment. If you paid by credit card, expect the refund to show on your account within the next 4 to 7 business days. If you paid by bank wire, cash, or another method that needs special processing, the refund is issued by check.
International bank wire purchases are refunded in USD at the exchange rate from the time of purchase. Brilliant Earth is not responsible for currency differences or fees charged by your bank.
| Stage | Typical Timing |
|---|---|
| Authorization number valid | 7 days from issue |
| Refund processed | About 5 business days after receipt |
| Credit card refund visible | 4 to 7 business days after processing |
Returning Engraved Rings
An engraved ring can be returned, but you will pay a $40 fee for Brilliant Earth to remove the custom engraving. Engraved rings must also be returned by phone instead of through the online portal.
If you are unsure about a personalized message, wait until you are certain of the size and style before adding engraving. That avoids both the fee and any complications with your return.
Returning Custom or Create Your Own Jewelry
Custom designed jewelry is excluded from the standard return policy. Create Your Own fine jewelry and Create Your Own engagement rings are handled by phone, so call before you assume what applies to your order.
Because rules for custom work can differ from ready to ship pieces, confirm the details with customer service before you place a custom order. Ask specifically what happens if you change your mind.
Brilliant Earth Exchange Policy
Exchanges follow the same 30 day window as returns and are started by phone. This is helpful if you want a different size, setting, or style rather than a refund.
Keep in mind that items received as an exchange cannot be returned later. Think carefully before exchanging, since the replacement item is final once it ships to you.
Resizing Instead of Returning
If the only problem is fit, a resize may be a better choice than a return. Brilliant Earth offers one complimentary resize within 60 days regardless of sizing range, or up to 1 year if the size falls within the ring’s recommended sizing range. Resizing includes free shipping both ways.
Eternity rings and alternative metals such as tantalum or titanium cannot be resized, but they can be exchanged for free within 60 days. Custom, modified, and engraved rings can be resized within 1 year but are subject to resize fees. Only Brilliant Earth rings can be resized.
Be careful, because a ring that has been resized or modified is no longer eligible for return. Decide whether you want to keep the ring before you request a resize.
Comparative Purchasing Rule
Brilliant Earth does not allow comparative purchasing. This means buying several products with the plan of keeping one and returning the rest.
If an order looks comparative, Brilliant Earth may block it from shipping or from being returned. If you are undecided between styles, use the virtual try on, a free ring sizer, or a showroom or virtual appointment instead of ordering several pieces.
Lifetime Diamond Upgrade and Warranty vs Returns
Brilliant Earth offers a free lifetime manufacturing warranty on its fine jewelry and a free lifetime diamond upgrade program. These are not return options, and it helps to know the difference.
The diamond upgrade lets you exchange a loose natural diamond for credit toward a new natural diamond worth at least 1.5 times more. For lab grown diamonds, the new stone must be worth at least 2 times more. Purchases made through the upgrade program are final sale and cannot be returned or exchanged.
The warranty covers manufacturing defects, not normal wear, lost gemstones, or theft. Repairs by a jeweler that Brilliant Earth has not authorized will void the warranty. Watches carry a three year manufacturing warranty instead of a lifetime one.
Common Mistakes That Can Block Your Return
Most failed returns come down to a few avoidable errors.
- Waiting until the final day of the 30 day window to start the process
- Shipping without a return shipping authorization number
- Letting the authorization number expire after seven days
- Leaving out promotional gifts that came with the order
- Dropping the package in a FedEx drop box instead of a staffed location
- Having a ring resized, repaired, or modified before deciding to return it
- Ordering several items to compare and keeping only one
Tips for a Smooth Brilliant Earth Return
A little preparation saves time and stress, especially with high value jewelry.
- Start the return early, ideally with several days to spare.
- Save your order confirmation, return confirmation, and FedEx receipt until the refund appears.
- Take photos of the jewelry and the packed box before you seal it.
- Keep the original packaging and any documents until you are sure you are keeping the item.
- Use the free FedEx label, since it keeps your return insured.
How to Contact Brilliant Earth About a Return
The fastest way to start a return, exchange, or resize is by phone at 800.691.0952. Customer service can also help if you are unsure whether your order qualifies, or if your authorization number has expired.
You can also use the online chat or visit a showroom for help. For online returns under $1,000, use the return portal and keep your order number handy.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to return Brilliant Earth jewelry?
You have 30 days, counted from when your purchase is available for shipment or pickup. Orders placed between November 1 and December 15 fall under the extended holiday policy and can be returned through January 15.
Does Brilliant Earth accept returns without a receipt?
The official policy does not list a receipt as a requirement. You do need a return shipping authorization number, so call 800.691.0952 to start the return if you cannot find your order details.
Does Brilliant Earth charge for return shipping?
No. Brilliant Earth provides a free FedEx return label, and the package is fully insured when you follow the packing instructions.
Is there a restocking fee at Brilliant Earth?
The official return policy does not list a restocking fee. The only return related fee it mentions is $40 to remove engraving from an engraved ring.
Can I return an engagement ring after it has been resized?
No. Rings that have been resized or modified are not eligible for return. Decide whether you want to keep the ring before you request a resize.
Can I return an engraved ring to Brilliant Earth?
Yes, but a $40 fee applies to remove the custom engraving. Engraved rings must be returned by phone.
Can I return custom or personalized jewelry?
No. Custom designed jewelry and personalized fine jewelry, such as name necklaces, are not eligible for return.
How long does a Brilliant Earth refund take?
Refunds are processed about 5 business days after your return is received. Credit card refunds then take another 4 to 7 business days to show on your account.
Can I return a Brilliant Earth order online?
Yes, if the item is unworn, under $1,000, within the 30 day window, and shipped within the US. Larger orders, international orders, Create Your Own jewelry, and engraved rings must be returned by phone.
What happens if my return authorization expires?
Authorization numbers are active for seven days. Call 800.691.0952 to request a new one if yours has expired.
Can I return a Brilliant Earth gift card?
No. Gift cards are non-transferrable and cannot be returned or redeemed for cash. Any unused balance stays available under the same gift card reference code.
Can I return a diamond bought through the Lifetime Diamond Upgrade Program?
No. Items bought through that program are final sale and cannot be returned or exchanged.
